Why the copyright of AI generated images matters? Why this is the big deal?
I had been spending my afternoon playing around with an AI-generated image tool that I had stumbled upon online. It was a lot of fun, and I was really impressed with the results that I was getting. As I was happily creating new images, my boss suddenly appeared at my desk and asked me a question that caught me off guard.
“Who owns the copyright to these images that you’re creating?” He asked.
I was momentarily taken aback, as I had never really thought about the issue of copyright when it came to AI-generated images. After a moment’s contemplation, I realized that this was actually a really important question, and one that could have significant implications for the creative industry.
If everyone starts using AI-generated tools like this one to create images for their needs, it could potentially disrupt the entire creative industry. This would be especially damaging for individual creators who rely on their own unique styles and ideas to make a living. That raises tons of question into my head, which leads to my below research where I have tried to fill in all scenarios to understand this matter better.
What is Copyright?
Copyright is a legal concept that protects original creative works, such as literature, music, art, and films, from being used or reproduced without the permission of the creator or owner. It gives creators exclusive rights to their works, including the right to copy, distribute, and sell them.
What are AI generated images?
AI-generated images are images that are created by a computer using artificial intelligence. They can be created in a variety of ways, such as using machine learning algorithms to analyze and replicate the style of a particular artist, or by using AI to generate entirely new images from scratch. AI-generated images can be used for a variety of purposes, such as in advertising, design, or art.
Why the copyright of AI generated images matters? Why this is the big deal?
Copyright is important for AI-generated images because it determines who owns the rights to use and reproduce the images. If a person creates an AI-generated image, they would typically own the copyright to that image and would have the exclusive right to decide how it is used. This means that other people would need to obtain permission from the creator or owner in order to use the image in any way.
The issue of copyright becomes particularly important when it comes to AI-generated images because they are created by a computer, rather than a human being. This means that it may be unclear who owns the rights to the images, and there could be disputes over who has the right to use them.
For example, if an AI-generated image is created using someone else’s copyrighted work as a reference, it could potentially lead to a legal dispute over who owns the rights to the new image.
Overall, the copyright of AI-generated images is important because it helps to ensure that creators and owners are properly credited and compensated for their work, and it helps to protect the creative industry from the potential negative impacts of AI and automation.
because protecting A.I.-generated works with copyright is vital to promoting the production of socially valuable content.
What are preventive measure of major platforms to stop AI generated images?
Here are a few preventive measures that major platforms can take to stop AI-generated images, also known as deepfakes, from being disseminated on their platforms. These include:
1. Implementing detection technologies: Some platforms have developed technologies that can detect the presence of deepfakes & AI generated images and flag them for review. These technologies can use machine learning algorithms to analyze the visual and auditory characteristics of the content to determine whether it is authentic or fake.
2. Enforcing community guidelines: Most platforms have community guidelines that prohibit the dissemination of false or misleading information. This can include AI generated article and posts , which are often used to spread disinformation.
3. Providing education and resources: Some platforms provide resources and education to help users identify AI Creations and AI generated images and understand the risks associated with them. This can include guides on how to spot AI involvement and tips on how to verify the authenticity of images and videos.
4. Cooperating with researchers and policymakers: Many platforms are working with researchers and policymakers to understand the impacts of deepfakes & AI and develop strategies for combating them. This can include supporting research on deepfake detection technologies and collaborating with governments and other organizations to develop policies and guidelines for addressing the issue.
5. Removing & Banning AI generated from their platforms: When AI creation are detected on a platform, they can be removed to prevent their further dissemination. This can be done through manual review or automated processes that flag content for review.
Recently found an article on Getty Images notified users via email that they will no longer accept submissions created with AI-generative models such as DALL-E, Midjourney, Nightcafe, and Imagen, and that they will remove all previous AI-generated art from their platform if they can find it. Getty’s decision has been followed by Shutterstock and others.
What is our indian government take on this?
for now The Indian Copyright Act only recognises works created by humans and not AIs
Conclusion is sill no clear
It is certainly important to pay attention to the opinions and perspectives of experts in various fields, including the arts, as they can provide valuable insights and help to ensure that decisions are informed and balanced. However, it is also important to consider the views and perspectives of all stakeholders in any given situation, including the general public and those who may be affected by the decisions that are made. It is ultimately important to find a way to strike a balance between the needs and concerns of different groups and to make decisions that are fair and just.
In the end that discussion rises tons of question like
1. It is generally possible to sell AI-generated images, provided that they are not infringing on any copyrights or other intellectual property rights.
2. It is possible to sell AI-generated art as non-fungible tokens (NFTs), which are unique digital assets that can be bought and sold on certain online platforms.
3. It is generally possible to use AI-generated art for profits, provided that it is done in a legal and ethical manner.
4. The question of whether AI-generated art is “real” art is a subjective one and may depend on individual definitions of art and the criteria used to determine what qualifies as art.
5. Is AI can impact the need to protect databases and data sets in a number of ways.
I hope this all points made a point of my research. I’d love to hear your thoughts on it, so please leave them in the comments.